Depending on your taste in cars, the Infiniti G35/G37, Acura TL, or Ford Mustang could all be good choices. If you want a coupe, then that would rule out the Acura. These cars all differ in character, so drive them all and see which you like the best.
The Lexus IS is also a nice car, but will probably be more expensive than the above options.
You might also give the Hyundai Genesis Coupe a look. It's similar to the Infiniti, but a little less luxurious, for less money. The Genesis Coupe has been offered with two engines, a turbo four and a V6. Like the Infiniti, a sport suspension is optional, and might make the ride too firm for your taste.
Once you've had a chance to drive a few cars, post your impressions here. With more information on your likes and dislikes I might have more specific suggestions.