2005 Subaru Legacy Problems and Repair Histories
2005 Subaru Legacy problems reported via the Car Repair History and Car Reliability Surveys
See what people are saying about 2005 Subaru Legacy problems
More about the
Subaru Legacy
Non-members can see only ten 2005 Subaru Legacy problems and repair histories. Log in or join us to see them all.
Repair costs are in local units.
2005 Subaru Legacy 4dr Wagon
turbocharged 250hp 2.5L H4 5-speed shiftable automatic AWD
| Subaru Legacy in Texas, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Oct | 2009 | 69000 | First odometer entry | |
| Dec | 2009 | 79000 | 415 | Strong raw fuel smell in and around car; suspected fuel line/fuel injector leak. Dealer's pressure test and visual inspection showed "no problem". No fuel smell at pickup at dealer. Vibrating brake pedal indicated brake disc/rotor wear, and/or worn pads. Dealer performed brake pad replacement. Intermittent fault in dashboard causes "illumination level" setting to appear on odometer, even though ilumination level dial is not being adjusted. Dash temperature readout no longer accurately reflects outside temps. |
| Mar | 2010 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
| Subaru Legacy in Colorado, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Feb | 2009 | 48000 | First odometer entry | |
| May | 2009 | 50000 | 0 | Took it to the dealer to get driver's seatbelt fixed because it stopped retracting, repairs were done in a few hours and were covered by Subaru lifetime seatbelt warranty. |
| Jan | 2010 | 57000 | 127 | thermostat replaced, coolant flushed |
| Sep | 2011 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
| Subaru Legacy in Missouri, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Nov | 2008 | 32000 | First odometer entry | |
| Dec | 2009 | 47000 | 75 | Need to replace turbo wastegate actuator solenoid. Considered "emissions" so not covered under extended warranty. Has not affected car's driveability. Part is in stock and have appointment on Friday. |
| Jan | 2010 | 47000 | 0 | Wastegates in turbocharger had issues, and turbocharger was overboosting. The entire turbocharger was replaced under powertrain warranty. |
| Dec | 2012 | 76000 | 500 | Radiator was leaking. Turns out it had cracked. New replacement radiator installed. |
| Mar | 2013 | 78000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Ontario, Canada | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Oct | 2010 | 35960 | First odometer entry | |
| May | 2011 | 38440 | 400 | turbocharger blew, billowing smoke, nursed it to dealer. after MANY letters and LOADS of patience, dealer agreed to reimburse cost of the parts (about $1500, so I paid about $400 in labour). |
| Mar | 2012 | 45880 | 1124 | pads starting to separate from backing torsion bar bushings cracked |
| Jun | 2012 | 47740 | 124 | Engine running VERY rough. Diagnosed as a leaky vacuum hose under the intake manifold. |
| Aug | 2012 | 49880 | 1400 | needed to replace front sway bar links & bushings, rear trailing arm bushings & rear lateral links leaky differential shaft seal |
| Nov | 2012 | 52040 | 790 | vibration felt through steering, but no issue with wheel balance; replaced ft axle shaft assy - slightly improved, but not solved ... gave up. |
| Jan | 2013 | 52700 | 0 | vibration felt through steering |
| Subaru Legacy in New Jersey, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Oct | 2008 | 0 | Sunroof stuck in the middle of operation. Dealer fixed it(replaced the sunroof assembly) - covered under warranty. | |
| Apr | 2010 | 51700 | 0 | humming noise when driving at highway speed. R/R wheel bearing is broken. |
| Mar | 2012 | 78000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Pennsylvania, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jan | 2010 | 2500 | Turbo completely died and blew seals. Oil was thrown into the exhaust system and destroyed both catalytic converters. Cats were covered under emissions warranty, but needed new turbo and related parts. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Wisconsin, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jan | 2009 | 30000 | First odometer entry | |
| May | 2009 | 33000 | 900 | Replace brake pads - evidently no aftermarket pads available - mechanic had to order pads from Subaru. |
| Jul | 2009 | 37000 | 900 | Had to replace pads and rotors. A bit surprising at this relatively low mileage. |
| Jul | 2010 | 45000 | 0 | Driver's side front wheel bearing went. Replaced by dealer under warranty. |
| Mar | 2013 | 83000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Colorado, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jun | 2011 | 78000 | First odometer entry | |
| Dec | 2011 | 84000 | 0 | rear wheel bearing replace under warranty because of Subaru recall |
| Mar | 2012 | 86000 | 100 | replaced front rotors and pads |
| Oct | 2012 | 90000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Massachusetts, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| May | 2006 | 0 | Dealer replaced defective hood latch under warranty. Latch would un-latch on rough roads or at high speed (safety catch would always prevent hood from opening, however). | |
| Jun | 2006 | 0 | Replaced defective factory oil filter with re-designed part. Burnt oil fumes were entering the cabin when the vehicle was stationary, and only after the engine had warmed to operating temperature. A known problem with some 2005 Legacy's the dealer cover | |
| Apr | 2007 | 13000 | 0 | Cracked windshield required replacement; insurance paid 100%. Crack began at windshield edge, no defined impact site. Technician thought it might be a stress crack (i.e. defect in the glass). |
| Mar | 2010 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
| Subaru Legacy in California, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Sep | 2006 | 21000 | First odometer entry | |
| Jun | 2007 | 41000 | 0 | A "whirring sound" developed over time. I suspected wheel bearings but not sure if it was front or back. The shop dealer diagnosed it as the rear wheel bearings. So both Left and Right rear wheel bearings were replaced. Repair and replacement was covered |
| Nov | 2007 | 51000 | 0 | Turbo Charger died around 52,875K. It was in the shop for 7 days. (partly because of the Holiday and parts had to come from Manufacturer). |
| Subaru Legacy in Michigan, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Feb | 2006 | 19000 | First odometer entry | |
| Mar | 2008 | 42000 | 155 | Turbocharger failure. Subaru did a "goodwill" coverage for the costs because I had extensive receipts for maintenance. |
| Aug | 2011 | 86000 | 130 | drivers side front door lock actuator not functioning. oil dipstick gasket replaced. Solved oil leak. |
| Dec | 2012 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
2005 Subaru Legacy 4dr Wagon
turbocharged 250hp 2.5L H4 5-speed manual AWD
| Subaru Legacy in California, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jun | 2009 | 40000 | First odometer entry | |
| Nov | 2009 | 44000 | 0 | Blown turbo due to clogged oil filter on line leading to turbo. Apparently common problem on the 2005 Legacy GT's. Replacing unit with aftermarket turbo. |
| Jun | 2011 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
| Subaru Legacy in New York, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jun | 2010 | 107000 | First odometer entry | |
| Jul | 2010 | 107000 | 230 | Replaced driver's side front half shaft. Replaced lower control arm bushings, though still at 50 percent. |
| Dec | 2010 | 114000 | 15 | minor; passenger side low-beam headlight. Simple DIY replacement $14 I've had the car since 107K, so no idea how many miles on that bulb. |
| Apr | 2011 | 121000 | 90 | Replaced driver side oil control valve. Starting to fail, although no significant problem with engine (yet). |
| Sep | 2012 | 140000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Washington, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Apr | 2006 | 9000 | First odometer entry | |
| May | 2007 | 26000 | 0 | Burnt out headlight- replaced both headlights at no charge. |
| Aug | 2010 | 57000 | 150 | Window motor for driver's door stopped working and was replaced. |
| Dec | 2012 | 80000 | 20 | Replaced left low beam headlight. |
| Jan | 2013 | 81000 | 20 | Power steering/alternator belt replaced. |
| Mar | 2013 | 82000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Massachusetts, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Sep | 2009 | 60000 | First odometer entry | |
| Sep | 2011 | 79000 | 300 | Leaky CV boot. |
| Subaru Legacy in Indiana, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jul | 2006 | 23000 | First odometer entry | |
| Feb | 2007 | 28000 | 0 | In extremely cold weather, the wheel bearings make loud noises when cornering and accelerating. Dealership attributed it to tire noise. Will revisit if it occurs with different tires. |
| Mar | 2007 | 29000 | 0 | TSB for Key Fob sensitivity. Case and buttons were replaced to prevent accidental activation. |
| Jun | 2007 | 32000 | 0 | Seat frame replaced for 3rd time due to squeaking |
| Apr | 2012 | 70000 | 200 | Right inner cv boot completely torn, left outer cracked and leaking grease with clicking when turning left. Both shafts replaced with aftermarket parts |
| Mar | 2013 | 75000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Massachusetts, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Dec | 2005 | 1000 | First odometer entry | |
| Jun | 2012 | 48000 | 350 | Frozen right front brake caliper |
| Mar | 2013 | 52000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Michigan, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Dec | 2011 | 134000 | First odometer entry | |
| Jan | 2012 | 134500 | 228 | Starter was going bad (bendix going out) and was replaced with remanufactured unit. |
| Aug | 2012 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
| Subaru Legacy in South Carolina, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jan | 2009 | 74000 | First odometer entry | |
| Jan | 2010 | 95000 | 1500 | Ignition switch (tumbler)had to be replaced due to ignition switch sending signal that key was always in ignition switch and therefore could not use key fob, lock doors using electric door lock, etc. Throw-out bearing was fried. Replaced bearing, clutch and oh-so-expensive dual mass flywheel. RIDICULOUS!! Oh and I just lost my job a week ago. This is awesome! And the hits they just keep a coming... |
| Jan | 2011 | 108000 | 1300 | Leaking (oil) valve cover. Replaced time belt. |
| Dec | 2011 | 123000 | 120 | Idler for accessory belt was noisy in cold weather. Replaced and fixed. |
| Oct | 2012 | 137700 | 400 | Lower control arm bushings replaced on both sides. |
| Jan | 2013 | 142000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in North Carolina, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| May | 2012 | 110000 | First odometer entry | |
| Nov | 2012 | 123000 | 350 | Turbo uppipe developed a crack. replaced with aftermarket version. no problems since. |
| Subaru Legacy in California, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Nov | 2007 | 35000 | First odometer entry | |
| Mar | 2008 | 45000 | 0 | The floor mat hook came off and the clip migrated under the carpet. |
| Sep | 2008 | 56000 | 200 | Discovered torn lower control arm bushings -- Both sides. (Common issue on these cars when tracked/autocrossed) Replaced LCA bushing with re-enforced aftermarket bushings. |
| Oct | 2008 | 58000 | 500 | ABS sensor ring failed, requiring replacement of wheel bearing. Subaru currently refusing warranty coverage. Caused by design defect. |
| Jul | 2009 | 72000 | 40 | Coolant overflow/failed rad cap problem fixed per TSB 09-52-08 |
| Dec | 2009 | 75000 | 0 | Oil consumption >1L per 1000mi. Leakdown and compression test. 60% loss -- 105 psi (normal 175-145psi). Suspect piston ring failure. Note: passed later test, now suspect turbo. |
| Jun | 2010 | 84000 | 1100 | Radiator had a blockage. Rodded out radiator and replaced coolant. Shop also found intercooler leaking ($800 of repair in parts, replaced with aftermarket part). This was likely caused by aftermarket parts. |
| Aug | 2010 | 86700 | 500 | Front drivers wheel bearing. |
| May | 2011 | 95000 | 5400 | Two blown up piston rings Third gear shredded |
| Jul | 2011 | 98000 | 800 | Inner CV boot on pass side tore, spewing grease over exhaust manifold resulting in smoke. Inner CV boot, drivers side leaking. Replaced. Discovered during problem 1. Ball joint boot torn. Replaced Fluid filled mount was leaking. Replaced. Dealer had never seen anything like it. (Tracked car) Light power steering leak from boots. Leak is extremely minor, no notable drop in fluid level in reservoir. Dealer recommends leaving alone. |
| Sep | 2011 | 104000 | 900 | Replaced timing belt and accessories according to manufacturer interval (105k mi). |
| Nov | 2011 | 108500 | 240 | Replaced squealing AC tensioner. |
| Apr | 2012 | 116000 | 0 | Found oil leak in a hose. Put over to order parts. Possible warranty item from engine replacement. |
| Jun | 2012 | 117000 | 300 | Leak in hose repaired. Had to replace intake hose as well as it was looking rough. |
| Oct | 2012 | 121300 | 550 | Front driver's wheel bearing replaced. |
| Mar | 2013 | 129000 | 100 | Power steering system was leaking. Replaced an O-ring. |
| Subaru Legacy in Ohio, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Sep | 2005 | 0 | First odometer entry | |
| Feb | 2007 | 10000 | 0 | Loose cargo net attachment repaired. Also towed in for oil light, but problem caused by aftermarket Mobil 1 filter. |
| Apr | 2007 | 11000 | 0 | They repaired a loose windshield wiper arm attachment. I was told by the dealer they are designed to loosen themselves so nothing breaks if there is resistance. This was caused by snow. Took 4 days because they entered wrong area code. |
| Jul | 2008 | 20000 | 0 | Passenger seat belt alarm - parts ordered Reported trim problem. We forgot it when we dropped off the car. we called the dealer ~ 1 hour after the car was dropped off. They didn't add it to the work order and ignored it. Cargo net anchor fell off the car for the second time. They reinstalled it. Black sooty buildup at exhaust pipe tips. Dealer said this is normal. Our other car, with a turbocharged engine alos, does not have any evidence of soot at the tail pipe. Greasy build-up on front right strut. (driver's side strut failed and leaked when car was ~2 months old). Dealer states there is no leak even though this is the 2nd greasy build-up. I cleaned off the 1st one to see if it recurred After driving ~ 15-20 minutes to get to interstate, exhaust smokes so you can't see out the rearview mirror accelerating onto the freeway in cold weather. Dealer says this is normal. Car hesitates or misses, occaisionally when driving 35-40 mph in 3rd gear, cruise on or not. They reflashed the engine contol module. It helped decrease the frequency, but did not eliminate the problem. |
| Dec | 2008 | 22000 | 0 | Front passenger seatbelt alarm sounds with no passenger in the seat. We have to fasten the seatbelt over the empty seat to silence the alarm. Dealer says they don't know what's wrong after their repair failed after two hours of departing the dealership. Driver's door vinyl trim has a defect which the dealer refuses to repair under the warranty. This was reported last July, but they ignored it then also. |
| Jul | 2010 | 37000 | 0 | Rear rubber bushings that mount somewhat triangular shaped part (don't know name) under the front struts to the car underbody are tearing on both the driver and passenger sides. They decided the split in the suspension bushing was normal. |
| Apr | 2011 | 43700 | 0 | Left rear wheel bearing was worn and making a loud noise. Dealership didn't have time to repair it and scheduled me to return the following week. They had the part in stock. Left rear wheel bearing was replaced. We never received the letter Subaru supposedly mailed to owners identifiing this as a potential problem. I wonder how long it will be until the other side will need replacement? |
| Mar | 2012 | 50000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Texas, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Sep | 2006 | 26000 | First odometer entry | |
| Sep | 2007 | 42000 | 176 | OBD reported "system too lean", inspected/cleaned injectors, checked/adjusted all intake connections and junctions. |
| Jun | 2008 | 50000 | 0 | AC capacity was mediocre but tolerable, but evaporator coil would "freeze up" in extended use. Tech said there was no problem but in his vacuum/refill of system apparently fixed something. Increased AC capacity and no freezing up since. |
| Oct | 2008 | 52000 | 215 | Brake service (rear) recommended on previous oil change. Wear indicator noise just started in mid-October so I scheduled the pad replacement with a regular oil-change service. |
| Mar | 2009 | 54000 | 0 | A bolt backed out of the tensioner for the accessory drive belt that runs the alternator and power steering. Alerted by belt squeal, I repaired this myself in a Wal-Mart parking lot because the bolt was still present, just loose from the tensioner. |
| Sep | 2011 | 66000 | 631 | passenger-side CV boot cracked and leaking lubricant, removed, cleaned, lubricated and installed new CV boot. Front stabilizer bar ends and bushings cracked. Removed stabilizer, replaced bar ends and bushings, reassembled. |
| Mar | 2013 | 78000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Connecticut, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| May | 2009 | 0 | replace turbo | |
| Sep | 2012 | 72000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Oregon, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Feb | 2008 | 32000 | First odometer entry | |
| Apr | 2008 | 34000 | 0 | Drivers all weather floor mat worn through. Driver side rear window seal coming apart. |
| Jun | 2008 | 36000 | 0 | Worn through driver door body weather stripping. Worn through driver door body weather stripping. |
| Jun | 2011 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
| Subaru Legacy in Texas, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jan | 2008 | 24000 | First odometer entry | |
| Oct | 2008 | 31000 | 30 | Headlamps replaced. The 2005 LGT is notorious for short-lived lamps due to daytime running lights and I'm just out of warranty. |
| Jan | 2012 | 55700 | 1200 | Replace worn clutch. Also required flywheel replacement. |
| Mar | 2013 | 63000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Alabama, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jun | 2011 | 71000 | First odometer entry | |
| Nov | 2011 | 73700 | 700 | Clutch required replacement. The lining wore out. I replaced clutch, pressure plate, flywheel, and throwout and pilot bearings, using the later 07+ single-mass flywheel design. I did not experience the grooving of the quill reported by others on LegacyGT. |
| Mar | 2013 | 99000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Massachusetts, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| May | 2006 | 6000 | First odometer entry | |
| Apr | 2009 | 42000 | 0 | Rear door window weatherstripping came loose. |
| Jun | 2009 | 43000 | 0 | Left and right rear wheel bearings replaced under factory warranty. |
| Nov | 2011 | 65500 | 145 | Clutch fork into transmision/bellhousing squeaks and binds at end of travel. Dealer greased, but no effect. Was told transmission must be removed to solve the problem. |
| Mar | 2013 | 77000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in New Hampshire, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| May | 2007 | 0 | Warranty-replaced exterior rubber trim against lower part of rear passenger window. | |
| Mar | 2010 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
| Subaru Legacy in Massachusetts, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Feb | 2010 | 39000 | First odometer entry | |
| Aug | 2010 | 48000 | 650 | Left front caliper seized due to broken dust seal and corrosion. Caliper cylinder bore was pitted, so had to be replaced. |
| May | 2011 | 60000 | 300 | Problem: Front sway bar endlinks wore out and failed (likely due to hard cornering), causing clunking sounds and steering response issues at low speeds. Endlinks were replaced with OEM links by an independent shop. |
| Jan | 2012 | 72000 | 200 | Heat only worked on driver side. Required flush of heater core to resolve. |
| Mar | 2012 | 76000 | 139 | replaced rear lift gate supports. The gas charged support cylinders had given out. |
| Mar | 2013 | 94000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
2005 Subaru Legacy 4dr Wagon
168-horsepower 2.5L H4 5-speed manual AWD
| Subaru Legacy in New York, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Oct | 2012 | 136000 | First odometer entry | |
| Nov | 2012 | 136000 | 0 | Head gasket leaked, oil pump leaked Windshield rusted out. |
| Subaru Legacy in Pennsylvania, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| May | 2011 | 92000 | First odometer entry | |
| Jun | 2011 | 94000 | 700 | Previously had complained on temporary severe engine miss after wet sitting in wet weather but dealer could not find. I finally left car until they found. Was bad coil pack. Because of several other expensive repairs this year, Subaru most. |
| Jul | 2011 | 95000 | 320 | Tailgate electric lock stopped working. Had replaced. |
| Subaru Legacy in California, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jun | 2005 | 0 | Power Steering hose | |
| Mar | 2013 | 42000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Maine, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Apr | 2009 | 68000 | First odometer entry | |
| May | 2009 | 69000 | 270 | replaced front struts and did alignment. |
| Jun | 2009 | 71000 | 300 | Dealer mechanic discovered minor oil leak in head gasket, will keep an eye on it and fix with extended warranty when it gets worse. Rear brakes wore out, turned rotors and replaced pads. |
| Sep | 2009 | 74000 | 150 | Front brakes finally wore out at 74,000 miles. |
| Jan | 2010 | 80000 | 250 | Small oil and Coolant leak from head gasket, gasket replaced under extended warrenty. mechanic discovered thermostat was sticking, they replaced thermostat, at my cost for the part. idler pulley for timing belt going bad, replaced under extended warranty, I had to pay for a new timing belt. power steering hose had bad leak, replaced under extended warranty. |
| Feb | 2010 | 82000 | 90 | heater core clogged and had no heat on passenger side after January repairs. The internet said it was a common problem for my year Subaru and dealer usually repaired, but I had to pay for them to flush out the cooling system. |
| Mar | 2010 | 83500 | 40 | Wheel stud broke after lug nut was off. I bought a new stud and mechanic replaced it. Studs and nuts have been a weak link as I have replace several of each in the last 3 years. |
| Jun | 2010 | 88000 | 300 | Dealer said 50 deg. air from AC is too warm, I agreed. They replace AC fluid and added dye, said the old stuff was warn out (didn't think it could go bad). Cost me $300 and it still cools to 50 deg. Warranty runs out in 10 days. |
| Mar | 2011 | 103000 | 250 | Front wheel bearing replaced. |
| Sep | 2011 | 113000 | 200 | Bad vibration over 55mph. Vibrations shakes steering wheel and car, it cycles through no vibrations for 1 minute, bad vibration for 4 minutes. Dealer verified. They cleaned rust from rims and brakes, it was worse and it cost me a lot. |
| Nov | 2011 | 115700 | 1500 | Local shop cleaned all moving brake parts and that fixed the bad vibration the dealer couldn't fix. |
| Apr | 2012 | 123500 | 150 | Cruise kicks off, then engine pings, and surges, after about a minute it acts normal. NO CODES! Replaced spark plugs and knock sensor. It still has the problem. |
| May | 2012 | 125000 | 400 | Engine still pings, misses, surges, stalls, has no power, or has great power while still doing the above. On a rare occasion it will run perfectly for a few min. Subaru said it was my gas and wouldn't look further. After 30 tanks of gas! |
| Jun | 2012 | 126000 | 220 | Local shop put in a used computer, 3 months of problems are now fixed. |
| Sep | 2012 | 132000 | 130 | Sears said it was worn out, I agree, as the car feels tighter now. |
| Mar | 2013 | 142000 | 400 | Rear spoiler broke and fell off, had to buy new one. |
| Subaru Legacy in Nova Scotia, Canada | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Sep | 2011 | 84320 | First odometer entry | |
| Nov | 2011 | 85220 | 600 | Gas tank leak due to rust in top front passenger side corner (ridiculously bad design of the tank, poor corrosion prevention, and expensive to replace). Tank was replaced by a used one. |
| Oct | 2012 | 97800 | 0 | Replacement gas tank leaks (just like the original). While this was not a new tank, it was installed as a used tank in good condition, for a fraction of the cost of a new one. Inspection only - no work was authorized due to cost/history. |
| Mar | 2013 | 104160 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Minnesota, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Sep | 2006 | 20000 | First odometer entry | |
| Jul | 2007 | 28000 | 0 | Air Cond Condenser leak |
| Aug | 2007 | 29000 | 0 | Air conditioning condenser failure. |
| May | 2010 | 59000 | 278 | AC failed to cool, dealer evacuated & recharged. Can't find leak. |
| Jun | 2010 | 62000 | 650 | On original trip, dealer could not find leak. On latest trip, dealer found leak in condenser and replaced condenser. |
| Apr | 2011 | 71000 | 0 | Right rear wheel bearing failure. Repair cost covered by factory. |
| Dec | 2011 | 78000 | 0 | Wheel bearing failure, replaced under factory warranty (Subaru extended factory warranty on wheel bearings to 84k miles) |
| Mar | 2013 | 90000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
2005 Subaru Legacy 4dr Wagon
168-horsepower 2.5L H4 4-speed shiftable automatic AWD
| Subaru Legacy in Arizona, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Oct | 2009 | 73000 | First odometer entry | |
| Dec | 2009 | 75000 | 550 | Replaced spark plugs and oil change, which revealed that driver side rear strut was blown and that the original battery was not holding a charge. Altogether cost was about 550.00 |
| May | 2010 | 84500 | 1000 | Timing belt and tensioner's replaced, belt replaced. front bushings replaced. |
| Oct | 2010 | 94000 | 700 | Routine 90,000 maintenance. Flushed and replaced transmission/coolant/brakes fluids, oil, air filter, spark plugs etc., Replaced brakes front and back. |
| Dec | 2012 | 115000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Nova Scotia, Canada | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jun | 2009 | 49600 | First odometer entry | |
| Jan | 2010 | 61980 | 250 | Replace lower balljoint as result of safety inspection. |
| Aug | 2011 | 84060 | 350 | Left rear door lock actuator and cable seized and replaced. Door would not open. |
| Mar | 2013 | 107260 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Washington, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Sep | 2006 | 0 | Replace front struts. Replace rear wheel bearing. | |
| Jun | 2009 | 58000 | 0 | Replace right rear wheel bearing. |
| Dec | 2012 | 95000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Colorado, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Oct | 2011 | 106000 | First odometer entry | |
| Mar | 2013 | 160000 | 600 | Symptoms: check engine light; rough idle after engine warm. Solution: Valve ring went bad; reworked valve guide, replaced head gasket. |
2005 Subaru Legacy 4dr Sedan
turbocharged 250hp 2.5L H4 5-speed shiftable automatic AWD
| Subaru Legacy in Quebec, Canada | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Mar | 2012 | 58900 | First odometer entry | |
| Apr | 2012 | 59520 | 305 | Replaced prematurely warped rotor. |
| Jan | 2013 | 63900 | 90 | replaced two belts |
| Apr | 2013 | 69440 | 485 | Rear rotors and pads replaced due to corrosion and wear |
| Subaru Legacy in Nova Scotia, Canada | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Mar | 2012 | 137640 | First odometer entry | |
| Apr | 2012 | 137640 | 600 | Plastic end tank on radiator cracked while driving, once up to temperature/pressure it sprayed all over the engine. The car went up on a flatbed to the dealer to have a new rad installed. After picking car up from radiator replacement, the car was surging badly, turned out to be a bad O2 sensor, very odd timing since nothing has failed in the last 70,000k |
| Subaru Legacy in Pennsylvania, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Oct | 2005 | 6000 | First odometer entry | |
| Mar | 2010 | 51000 | 900 | Replace steering rack |
| Dec | 2010 | 60000 | 250 | During an inspection, mechanic found a failing ball joint. Ball joint replaced and vehicle aligned on the same day. |
| Dec | 2011 | 71000 | 350 | The AC drain tube clogged causing water damage to the heater blower motor. Drain tube was cleared and blower motor replaced. |
| Oct | 2012 | 79000 | 200 | Replaced rear sway bar end links |
| Mar | 2013 | 85000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Minnesota, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Mar | 2012 | 80000 | First odometer entry | |
| Jun | 2012 | 83000 | 600 | Both front CV joints replaced. Took 3 days because I did one, then the other. The passenger's side joint went out during the the test drive, and was replaced again the next day. |
| Jul | 2012 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
| Subaru Legacy in Great Britain | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Feb | 2012 | 69000 | First odometer entry | |
| May | 2012 | 71000 | 120 | Rear shock absorber |
| Subaru Legacy in Massachusetts, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Apr | 2007 | 45000 | First odometer entry | |
| May | 2007 | 46000 | 300 | Damaged stuck front disc brake pad replaced, rotor turned. |
| Mar | 2010 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
| Subaru Legacy in Ontario, Canada | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| May | 2011 | 91760 | First odometer entry | |
| Jul | 2011 | 93620 | 240 | #3 Cylinder coil needed to be replaced |
| Subaru Legacy in North Carolina, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Nov | 2007 | 63000 | First odometer entry | |
| Jul | 2011 | 134000 | 190 | Cylinder 4 ignition coil was causing misfire and needed replacement. The actual repair took 1 day, the other days were for troubleshooting. Car in and out of shop (~1 day/week) for about a month to identify cause of misfire. |
| Nov | 2011 | 145000 | 300 | Right inner axle boot worn, replaced |
| Jan | 2012 | 149700 | 700 | Replaced front suspension |
| Mar | 2013 | 166000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Utah, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jun | 2010 | 94000 | First odometer entry | |
| Dec | 2010 | 100000 | 150 | Leaking fuel line connections at fuel injectors. Retightened clamps. |
| Apr | 2011 | 105700 | 800 | Timing belt service. |
| Jan | 2012 | 115000 | 660 | Leaking PS system, new O-ring on suction hose where it meets PS pump fixed the problem. Valve cover gasket leaking Cracked CV boot front passenger side, new axle installed |
| Dec | 2012 | 126000 | 600 | Slight crack in intercooler. Replaced intercooler. |
| Apr | 2013 | 129000 | 500 | There was a crack in the plastic top part of the radiator, replaced radiator. |
| Subaru Legacy in Texas, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Aug | 2010 | 48000 | First odometer entry | |
| May | 2011 | 59000 | 210 | CV boot was cracked and leaking oil on front passenger side. Boot replaced and axle re-lubricated. Problem was identified by mechanic while the car was in to resurface front brake rotors. |
| Dec | 2011 | 65000 | 600 | Engine gasket worn out and leaking oil. Gasket replaced. Coolant tubing and connector deteriorated and was leaking coolant. Radiator thermostat soaked in coolant and also replaced as a precaution. |
| Mar | 2012 | 70000 | 800 | Power steering pump leaking fluid |
| May | 2012 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
2005 Subaru Legacy 4dr Sedan
turbocharged 250hp 2.5L H4 5-speed manual AWD
| Subaru Legacy in New Hampshire, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Dec | 2011 | 99000 | First odometer entry | |
| Feb | 2013 | 108300 | 800 | Both front calipers were frozen and required replacement. |
| Mar | 2013 | 109000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Washington, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Sep | 2007 | 0 | Torn axle boot, the dealer service department choose to call it a warranty repair even though it was just outside of the power train warranty | |
| Jun | 2012 | 100000 | 2050 | Clutch throw out bearing failure, augmented by the notorious transmission snout grooving. Fixed with a new clutch assembly and a transmission snout sleeve kit(tsk3). Also got 2 axle seals and a control arm bushing as maintenance. |
| Mar | 2013 | 106000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Pennsylvania, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Dec | 2009 | 40000 | First odometer entry | |
| Jul | 2010 | 47000 | 350 | Front Right bearing was making a lot of noise and diagnosed by both the dealer and a non-dealer mechanic as faulty and need of replacement. After replacement however, the noise is still there. |
| Aug | 2012 | 51000 | 0 | Had to replace alternator belt as the old one came of the pulley and was damaged. |
| Subaru Legacy in Arizona, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Sep | 2007 | 36000 | First odometer entry | |
| Nov | 2008 | 47000 | 100 | Display on radio-HVAC unit went out, though unit still functioned. Replacement was ordered. Replacement installed approx 1 week later. Paid $100 deductible on extended warranty |
| May | 2010 | 61000 | 100 | torn cv joint boot |
| Mar | 2013 | 84000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Alaska, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Aug | 2006 | 14000 | First odometer entry | |
| Mar | 2008 | 42000 | 50 | Faulty fuel injector, causing misfire in cylinder 3. |
| May | 2009 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
| Subaru Legacy in Georgia, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jul | 2007 | 28000 | First odometer entry | |
| Aug | 2007 | 29000 | 0 | 6-CD changer would get stuck on one track and constantly repeat or just act like it's playing with no sound. Problem was worse with brand new CD's often locking up by the 3rd track. It would happen often on hot days, but I live in GA so every day is hot. Originally brought car in for check engine light and the Turbo Fan Relay recall. The car ran rough at idle and studdered at 2800rpm. Dealer replaced the ECM(computer). Pulsation in steering when applying the brakes. Dealer replaced rear rotors and pads but it still had a slight pulsation. They ordered front rotors and brakes. Bringing car back to dealer when parts arrive. Note: This is not going to solve the problem sin |
| Nov | 2007 | 34000 | 0 | Rough idle again and poor performance. Dealer replace #2 injector, but did not solve the problem. Possibly another injector is defective along with a needed ECM reflash dealer didn't have time to complete last visit. Bringing back to dealer to fix again. Steering pulse was explained to be normal due to AWD torque shirt during tight turning. Brake pulsation was not resolved due to lack of time. Bringing car back to dealer to have brake problem addressed. Front drivers side headlight burned out for the 2nd time in 18 months. Replaced by dealer under warranty. |
| Dec | 2007 | 37000 | 542 | Rough idle and poor performance still exist, dealers dianostic computer was down and could not determine which injector was bad. Must go back to dealer, AGAIN! Whinning and vibration coming from left rear of car. Dealer replaced left rear wheel bearing fixing the problem. Rough idle and poor performance problem still. Different dealer(out of town) did not find anything wrong with the injectors but had fouled up plugs. Preformed 30,000 service which included new plugs, carbon cleaning, etc. Ran great for about 100 miles the |
| Apr | 2008 | 41000 | 0 | Replaced the number 4 injector and the car has been running great. |
| Dec | 2008 | 51000 | 86 | I had the turbo banjo bolt removed after reading a TSB that the banjo filter could become clogged and starve the turbo of oil causing it to seize. Dealer recommended removal of filter rather than cleaning every 3000 miles at a cost of $90 in labor. |
| Dec | 2009 | 63000 | 854 | The throw-out bearing in the clutch self destructed itself. Which inturn damaged the the fly wheel and the transmission case snout it is housed on. I naturally replaced all my clutch parts while they were in there. That bearing should not die at 60k. |
| Jul | 2010 | 70700 | 350 | Replaced the Front passenger side half-shaft becasue CV boot closest to trasmission was torn. Typical problem on turbo models due to how close the boot is to the exhaust manifold. Easy repair, but axle was very expensive. |
| Mar | 2012 | 92000 | 1500 | Power steering pump leak had to be replaced. Valve cover gasket leak. Typical expensive repair on all subaru's around 100k. Had them replaced along with I minor oil leak from the oil filter attachment. Boot on front driver axle/cv was cracked. Replaced the axle. |
| Oct | 2012 | 103000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Rhode Island, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Aug | 2009 | 0 | Rear wheel bearings, covered under extended warranty. | |
| Oct | 2009 | 78000 | 0 | Rear wheel bearing noisy, replaced under an extended warranty. |
| Apr | 2012 | 117700 | 83 | Rear sway bar links wore out, noisy/clunking sound. |
| Jan | 2013 | 132000 | 135 | Transfer gear bearings in the center differental were noisy. Replaced 2 bearings. |
| Subaru Legacy in Illinois, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jul | 2008 | 0 | purchased vehicle-1 owner | |
| Jan | 2009 | 200 | Left rear wheel bearing replaced, Contacted SOA and they sent a reimbursement check, fixed at local shop. | |
| Jun | 2009 | 0 | Power steering fluid boiled under normal driving conditions and reservoir overflowed. replaced powersteering oil and oem belt. $50 | |
| Aug | 2010 | 87000 | 300 | Passanger Inner CV Boot ripped. |
| Mar | 2011 | 91000 | 200 | front driver side wheel bearing needed a replacement. 2 weeks prior the noise was hardly noticable, it got very loud, very fast, and it pulled left as it the alignment off. When it was replaced the alignment pulled slightly right. |
| Oct | 2011 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
| Subaru Legacy in Singapore | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jul | 2010 | 47120 | First odometer entry | |
| Aug | 2011 | 60140 | 80 | Replacement of CV boot (right) |
| Sep | 2011 | 60760 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in North Dakota, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Aug | 2008 | 34000 | First odometer entry | |
| Jul | 2011 | 53000 | 350 | Leaking power steering pump replaced |
| May | 2012 | 59300 | 195 | Recharge, checked for leaks, none found |
| Aug | 2012 | 62500 | 83 | Replaced both accessory drive belts |
| Oct | 2012 | 63700 | 0 | Replaced passenger side rear wheel bearing. Common problem, Subaru has extended the warranty to 8 years, 100k miles. |
| Mar | 2013 | 66000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in New York, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| May | 2011 | 105000 | First odometer entry | |
| Jun | 2011 | 106000 | 1100 | diagnose and replace car computer replaced AC compressor and expansion valve |
| Dec | 2011 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
2005 Subaru Legacy 4dr Sedan
168-horsepower 2.5L H4 5-speed manual AWD
| Subaru Legacy in Ontario, Canada | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Nov | 2006 | 11160 | First odometer entry | |
| Dec | 2006 | 12400 | 0 | Passenger side seatbelt warning alarm and audible alarm on even when there is no passenger. Dealer has ordered a new part which is covered by warranty. |
| Mar | 2007 | 16120 | 0 | The alarm sound and overhead indicator for the passenger seat belt not used, is actve whether there is a person sitting at the seat or not. The dealer says Subaru is working on the problem |
| May | 2007 | 17980 | 0 | The dealer corrected an earlier problem with the passenger side seat belt alarm active when there was no one in the seat. New sensor added and calibrated Replaced headlight and no charge do to delay in fixing problem number one. |
| Oct | 2007 | 22320 | 0 | The four way flashers did not work. Dealer discovered the problem and fixed no charge. |
| Jan | 2008 | 24180 | 0 | Driver side headlight keeps failing usually in less than a month. Dealer fixed and put in long life bulbs. |
| Mar | 2013 | 81840 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Ontario, Canada | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Mar | 2010 | 64480 | First odometer entry | |
| Sep | 2010 | 74400 | 0 | Vibration between 2-2.5k RPM. Turned out to be a loose exhaust heat shield; all that was required was a quick tightening. |
| Dec | 2010 | 77500 | 300 | Left-rear wheel bearing. |
| Jan | 2011 | 79980 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
2005 Subaru Legacy 4dr Sedan
168-horsepower 2.5L H4 4-speed shiftable automatic AWD
| Subaru Legacy in North Carolina, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Nov | 2006 | 21000 | First odometer entry | |
| Sep | 2011 | 65000 | 350 | Replaced valve cover gaskets. |
| Feb | 2012 | 69500 | 75 | Broken radiator cap. Replaced & topped off coolant. |
| Oct | 2012 | 74000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Pennsylvania, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| May | 2010 | 58000 | First odometer entry | |
| Jun | 2010 | 59800 | 22 | Driver side headlight bulb OEM |
| Jan | 2011 | 68000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in New York, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Feb | 2012 | 114000 | First odometer entry | |
| Mar | 2012 | 115000 | 0 | General brake maintenance, loose calipers - front passenger side brake |
| Apr | 2012 | 116000 | 1200 | Head gasket, timing belt and water pump replacement. |
| Mar | 2013 | 127000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Ontario, Canada | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| May | 2009 | 63240 | First odometer entry | |
| Aug | 2010 | 70060 | 10 | Right low-beam light burned out. Replaced myself. |
| Jan | 2011 | 71920 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
| Subaru Legacy in Peru | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Aug | 2010 | 49600 | First odometer entry | |
| Nov | 2010 | 52060 | 270 | Rear doors power locks not working. Actuators replaced |
| Nov | 2012 | Most recent odometer entry. | ||
| Subaru Legacy in Illinois, United States | ||||
| Month | Year | Odometer (in miles) |
Cost | Problem/Repair Description |
| Jun | 2010 | 50000 | First odometer entry | |
| Aug | 2010 | 53000 | 515 | Standard Brake repair: Replace pads and cut or replace rotors on all four wheels. |
| Apr | 2013 | 73000 | Most recent odometer entry. | |
Expert 2005 Subaru Legacy Repair Advice
Non-members can see only ten 2005 Subaru Legacy problems and repair histories. Log in or join us to see them all.
What People Are Saying about Problems with the 2005 Subaru Legacy
blog comments powered by Disqus
